
Working Capital Assessment — Operating Cycle, the Tandon Committee's MPBF Methods I and II, the Nayak Turnover Method (20% of Sales) for Limits up to ₹5 Crore, the Cash Budget Method, Margin, Drawing Power and How the Cash-Credit Limit Is Actually Fixed
Video Explanation & Insights
Maximum Permissible Bank Finance (MPBF) — the Tandon Committee methods
4 videos on this topic
The operating cycle and the working-capital gap
Working capital is the money locked in the cycle from paying for raw material to collecting from the customer. Banks build it up in days: raw-material holding, work-in-progress, finished-goods holding and debtor collection add to the cycle; the credit received from suppliers reduces it. Each element is valued at the appropriate cost (raw material at purchase cost, WIP and finished goods at cost of production, debtors at sale price) to arrive at gross current assets. Current liabilities other than bank borrowing — creditors, advances from customers, statutory dues — are deducted to find the working-capital gap, and the bank funds a part of that gap, leaving the promoter to fund the margin.
| Element | Basis | Example (₹ lakh, annual figures) |
|---|---|---|
| Raw material | 45 days of annual consumption (₹360) | 45 ÷ 365 × 360 = 44 |
| Work in progress | 10 days of cost of production (₹480) | 13 |
| Finished goods | 30 days of cost of sales (₹500) | 41 |
| Debtors | 60 days of credit sales (₹600) | 99 |
| Other current assets (advances, deposits) | Actual | 8 |
| Gross current assets | 205 | |
| Less: creditors (30 days of purchases ₹370) | 30 | |
| Less: other current liabilities (advances, expenses payable) | 15 | |
| Working-capital gap | 160 |
Tandon Committee — MPBF Methods I and II
| Method | Formula | On the example | Current ratio implied |
|---|---|---|---|
| Method I | MPBF = 75% × (current assets − current liabilities other than bank borrowing) | 75% × 160 = 120; promoter margin 40 | About 1.17 |
| Method II | MPBF = 75% × current assets − current liabilities other than bank borrowing | 75% × 205 − 45 = 108.75; promoter margin 51.25 | 1.33 — the norm banks use |
| Method III (never adopted) | 75% × (current assets − core current assets) − other current liabilities | — | Higher |
- •Method II is the standard for limits above ₹5 crore (and for any borrower where the bank applies the 'second method of lending'); it forces 25% of current assets to come from long-term funds, which is the 1.33 current ratio.
- •If the actual net working capital is below the required margin, the shortfall is either brought in by the promoter, converted into a working-capital term loan (WCTL) repayable over a few years, or the limit is reduced.
- •The Chore Committee (1979) added that the cash-credit limit should be reviewed annually with the CMA and that the bank may fix a peak-level and non-peak-level limit for seasonal units.
- •Holding levels are not free: banks compare your days with industry norms and with your own past; a sudden increase in debtor days in the projection is cut back.
Turnover method for MSMEs — limits up to ₹5 crore
- 1Estimate the projected annual turnover realistically (the bank checks it against GST returns and past growth).
- 2Working-capital requirement = 25% of projected turnover (assumes a three-month operating cycle).
- 3Bank finance = 20% of projected turnover; promoter's margin = 5% of turnover (i.e., 20% of the requirement), which must be visible as net working capital.
- 4Example: projected turnover ₹4 crore → working capital ₹1 crore → cash-credit limit ₹80 lakh → margin ₹20 lakh.
- 5Where the actual cycle is longer (say a six-month cycle in a seasonal trade), banks may assess by the Tandon method instead and sanction more; where it is shorter, the turnover method still gives the minimum for MSEs under RBI guidance.
- 6The limit is reviewed annually; enhancement needs the next year's projected turnover and the achieved sales of the current year.
Cash budget method and drawing power
- •Cash budget method: for contractors, real-estate developers, seasonal agro-processing (sugar, cotton ginning, rice milling), film and event businesses, the bank funds the peak deficit shown in a month-wise cash budget of receipts and payments; the limit is the highest cumulative deficit, with a margin, and it is drawn and repaid in step with the budget.
- •Drawing power (DP): within the sanctioned limit, the amount you may actually draw each month is computed from the stock and book-debt statement — stock at cost or market (lower) less unpaid creditors, and debtors up to the agreed age (90–120 days), each after the margin (typically 25% on stock, 40% on debtors). DP below the outstanding means an excess drawing and a possible SMA classification.
- •Margin and security: primary security is the hypothecated stock and debtors; collateral is negotiated separately; CGTMSE-covered limits need none.
- •Interest: cash credit is charged on the daily outstanding; a WCTL carve-out carries term-loan pricing; unutilised limits above ₹1 crore may attract a commitment charge.
- •Renewal: the annual review needs audited financials, CMA data for two years' actuals and two years' projections, stock audit for larger limits, and the current-year performance against the last projection.
The CMA data format in brief
| Form | Contents |
|---|---|
| Form I — Particulars of existing / proposed limits | Fund-based and non-fund-based limits, sanctioned and utilised |
| Form II — Operating statement | Sales, cost of production, operating profit, interest, depreciation, tax, PAT for 2 actual, 1 estimated and 2–3 projected years |
| Form III — Balance sheet analysis | Current assets, current liabilities, fixed assets, net worth, term liabilities, ratios |
| Form IV — Comparative statement of current assets and liabilities | Holding levels in days for each item |
| Form V — Computation of MPBF | Method I and II working |
| Form VI — Funds flow | Sources and uses, long-term surplus, changes in working capital |
Working capital: questions we are asked
Under the turnover method, about ₹60 lakh (20% of ₹3 crore) with ₹15 lakh margin from you; more if your operating cycle is genuinely longer and assessed under Tandon.
The limit is the ceiling sanctioned for the year; drawing power is the month's ceiling from the stock and debtor statement after margins — you can draw the lower of the two.
No — that is diversion of working capital; the bank will reduce the limit or reclassify the account. Take a term loan for the machine.
Debtors older than the agreed period (usually 90–120 days) are treated as doubtful and carry no drawing power; collect or provide for them.
By the cash budget method or with peak/non-peak limits — the limit is high in the buying season and falls after sales are realised.
Yes — the assessment by the applicable method, the six CMA forms, monthly stock statements and drawing-power working, and the annual renewal file.